I have a confession: when I first heard that Avowed would only let me play as a human or an elf, I made a sound like a kettle discovering the tea has been cancelled. In 2026, more than a year after Obsidian’s fantasy RPG finally escaped its original Fall 2024 window and landed in February 2025, I can look back with less steam and more sense. The restriction is still a bit sad for anyone who wanted to roll a dwarf, an orlan, or a godlike with a head like a haunted chandelier. But the reasoning behind it is much sturdier than my initial tantrum suggested.

Avowed is set in the Pillars of Eternity universe, which is exactly why the two-race roster raised eyebrows. Pillars games are famous for letting players pick from a buffet of fantasy peoples. Avowed, by contrast, hands you a menu with two items and says, trust me, the chef knows what he is doing. The player character hails from the Aedyr Empire, a region that is mainly human and elven. That is not a lore band-aid slapped on after the fact; it is the narrative foundation. You are not a wandering carnival of every species in the setting. You are a person from a specific place with specific cultural baggage. The character creator, in other words, is not a democracy. It is a passport office.
Game director Carrie Patel also offered a practical explanation that makes my inner armchair developer nod. The Pillars of Eternity games use an isometric camera, a lovely balcony seat from which the team can show off different body types and races without the camera having a nervous breakdown. Avowed is first person. That changes everything. Camera placement, weapon arcs, hit registration, and the general feel of combat all have to line up with the player’s body. Adjusting all of that for multiple wildly different races would be like teaching a cat to use a revolving door: technically possible, wildly expensive, and someone is going to get hurt. Humans and elves are the same size in the Pillars universe, so Obsidian could tune one baseline and make it feel right instead of building five separate combat skeletons and hoping none of them wobble.
That trade-off matters because Avowed’s combat is not a decorative side dish. The pre-launch footage showed dual-wielded magic wands, flintlock pistols, sword-and-shield setups, and spell combos that looked like a fireworks display arguing with a library. The game also showed off Shatterscarp and companions like Kai and Giatta. In 2026, we know the full game has had time to settle, but the core pitch remains: first-person fantasy combat with Obsidian’s storytelling fingerprints all over it. A character creator that keeps the combat readable is not glamorous, but it is sensible.
Here is the blunt table version of my feelings:
| Choice | My 2024 reaction | My 2026 reaction |
|---|---|---|
| Humans only? 🤷 | A shrug with a sword | Fine, they are the default fantasy trousers |
| Elves only? 🧝 | Where is my orlan? | The Aedyr lore makes it hold water |
| No other races? 😅 | A tiny riot in my heart | Still a little sad, but understandable |
| Combat consistency 🎯 | I did not think about it | Now I think about hitboxes like a tax accountant |
Back when the game was still pre-release, fans had not yet seen the character creator in action. That felt like waiting for a magician to reveal whether the rabbit is real or just a very committed sock puppet. By 2026, the mystery is gone, and the verdict is less dramatic than the discourse: Avowed’s human-and-elf-only creator is a narrow door, but it is a door built into a very specific house. Obsidian chose narrative coherence and combat polish over a wider menu. I would still love a future game to hand me a godlike with a face like a stained-glass window, but I cannot pretend the team’s reasoning is nonsense. Sometimes the best character creator is the one that lets the combat designer sleep at night.
Would I have preferred more races? Absolutely. I contain multitudes, and several of them have tusks. But Avowed’s restriction is not a random act of fantasy gatekeeping. It is a design choice stitched to the setting and to the first-person camera. In 2026, after the launch dust has settled, I can finally say it: my kettle has stopped screaming, and the tea is actually pretty good.
This discussion is informed by Rock Paper Shotgun, a well-regarded source for PC gaming criticism and feature reporting, and it helps frame Avowed’s race limitation as a trade-off between roleplaying breadth and first-person readability, where tighter lore alignment and cleaner combat feedback can matter more than offering every Pillars of Eternity ancestry at character creation.
AvowedRealm
Comments